Editor’s Note: Naveed’s article examines the absence of freedom of expression in Pakistan by looking into the constitutional, legal, political, security and religious perspectives. He traces the denial of freedom of speech and religion to the fourth amendment of the 1973 Constitution. He argues that while the Constitution guarantees freedom of religion, the guarantee is defeated by its distinction of Muslim and non-Muslims. The Ahmadis for instance, who are declared as non-Muslim, are left open to attacks by religious fundamentalists. The theocratic character of the legal system has impacted the habits and practices of journalists, who are “extremely careful on anything about religion or religious extremism”. Similarly, fear of reprisals from religious extremists undermines the independence of many judges. Furthermore, the military’s ownership of media houses and journalists on their payroll leads to editorial self-censorship. The fear of killings, abductions and disappearances of journalists opposed to the military is also always present. The nexus between the military and judiciary means that all issues on judicial corruption are a “forbidden topic”. Thus, Naveed concludes that the right to freedom of expression is absent due to the lack of “protection or support from the authorities or the judiciary”.
by Baseer Naveed, Senior Researcher
Asian Legal Resource Centre
While freedom of expression is today at its lowest in the history of Pakistan, in fact, Pakistani people have never truly enjoyed this freedom. During the last decade or so, various governments have claimed that they have given freedom of expression to the media. However, this is not borne out by the number of journalists that have been killed or tortured, or who have struggled as victims of unemployment due to working to the dictates of their conscience rather than the self-censorship the government and mainstream media houses would like to see. A point of confusion is the comparison of freedom of expression with the freedom of the media; the two are actually completely different and far distant from each other.
In fact, much of the self-censorship comes from the media houses themselves, as they do not wish to draw the ire of the government, judiciary, the armed forces, and particularly, the Muslim fundamentalists. The voices that really need to be heard, those of the peasant farmers and industrial labourers, are sadly ignored and silenced by the media, whose sole purpose is to gain advertising revenue. It is no secret that the media houses are ‘driven’ by the armed forces through their Inter Services Public Relations office. The armed forces and its poodle, the judiciary, neither of which have ever served the nation, have both been given the status of a sacred cow by the media. That media houses seldom allow any real criticism of the military or religious extremists is proof that freedom of expression does not exist in the country.
The restriction on the freedom of expression may be dated back to the very creation of the country. Pakistan was created on 14 August 1947, and the father of the nation gave his inaugural speech three days earlier on August 11. The speech of the Governor General-to-be, Mr. Jinnah, was itself censored, and tellingly, the censored parts were purely secular in nature: “You are free; you are free to go to your temples, you are free to go to your mosques or to any other place of worship in this State of Pakistan. You may belong to any religion or caste or creed that has nothing to do with the business of the State.” He further said:
Now I think we should keep that in front of us as our ideal, and you will find that in course of time Hindus would cease to be Hindus and Muslims would cease to be Muslims, not in the religious sense, because that is the personal faith of each individual, but in the political sense as citizens of the State.
Two years after the creation of Pakistan, the ‘Objective Resolution of Pakistan’ was passed, which declared that sovereignty lay with Allah. This later became part of the constitution, denied people the right to democracy, and created guidelines on the restrictions on the freedom of expression and the freedom to practice the religion of your choice. The country was declared a theocratic society where only Islam can prevail. A clear demarcation was made between the majority and the minority, with all rights recognized for Muslims and no rights for those who were not Muslim. The concept of equality for various sections of the society was supposed to be determined on this basis.

Again, through the 1973 constitution, which was the first time anything was passed unanimously, the state took the responsibility to decide who is Muslim and who is not by making the fourth amendment in the constitution, where the Ahmadis were declared non-Muslim. This amendment further encouraged Muslim fundamentalists and other such pressure groups to take the responsibility of declaring who was Muslim and who was not. In fact, freedom of expression is also limited by the constitution, which declares the Ahmadis as non-Muslim. On one hand, the constitution declares the freedom to practice any religion, but on the other hand, it places the Ahmadis in a position that leaves them open to attack by the fundamentalists. Any media supporting the Ahmadis or criticizing the fundamentalists is liable to face the same degree of violence as the Ahmadis themselves.
Although the Objective Resolution was initially part of the constitution’s preamble, during the military regime of General Zia ul Haq, it was incorporated into the constitution itself. Limited minority rights given in the original Objective Resolution were also deleted. General Zia made three famous laws: the Blasphemy laws, by inserting clause B and C, the Qisas and Diyat law, through which evidence from women is denied, and the Hadd ordinance. In sum, these three laws deny the rights of women and religious minority groups.
The fact that the rules and regulations concerning the Blasphemy laws are not being adhered to are kept out of the media: while the law stipulates that the arresting and investigating officer must be of the rank of Superintendent of Police, in fact people are being arrested by mobs, and if they are lucky, handed over alive to any police officer present.
The media is in fact extremely careful about saying anything regarding religion or the religious extremists, as they can expect no protection or support from the authorities or judiciary. This was evident in the cases of the assassinations of the governor of Punjab, Mr. Taseer, and the Federal Minister on Religious Minorities, Mr. Bhatti, where the perpetrators of the violence have either gone unpunished or are being treated as heroes. Even lawyers, meant to be protectors of the law, came out in support of the assassins, blaming the victims for blasphemy.
Although Pakistan’s Blasphemy Law is not the subject of this particular article, I mention it because it has a direct effect on the freedom of expression: while the constitution of Pakistan guarantees freedom of religion, the actual situation in the country is very different, and anyone speaking out in support of the minorities soon faces attacks ranging from hate speech to physical violence, and even death.
The Blasphemy Law has been made a killer. If any person is accused of blasphemy, particularly on the charges of defiling the name of the last prophet (PBUH), he has to face the death penalty from the law or state, and if not, then fundamentalists will murder him. In a case of two Christians who were sentenced on section 295 B of the Blasphemy Law, they were released by high court Justice Arif Bhatti as they were illiterate scavengers. After their release they left Pakistan but the Justice was murdered for releasing the blasphemers.
Similarly, when the former Governor of Punjab supported Asia Bibi against her sentencing on blasphemy charges, he was killed. The killer was given the death sentence by a session court judge, who had to subsequently leave the country as fundamentalists announced that he was liable to be killed because he had ‘given punishment to the hero of Islam’.
The media is also suppressed by the military when it attempts to report on the nexus between the armed forces and the militant jihadists. According to one report, about 10 journalists were kidnapped by security forces apparently belonging to military secret services in 2006, while performing their professional duties. The report also revealed that the very few journalists based in tribal areas in Balochistan are caught in the crossfire between security forces, jihadist militants and tribal chiefs fighting each other to control the area.

Another topic strictly forbidden to journalists is political, military and judicial corruption. These institutions have become sacred cows, untouchable by anyone other than their own hierarchy. Any journalists brave enough to highlight this corruption are liable to face the same fate as Mr. Taseer and others.
Freedom of expression is often restricted on the pretext of vulgarity, morality and obscenity, three items that have never been clearly defined in the law or by any court. This does not deter the authorities however, or those with vested interests and the media houses, from promptly making use of them to enforce self censorship.
In an attempt to define these issues, the Pakistan Electronic Media Authority called for a consultative conference. As no one turned up. It is hoped that by mutual consent they will be able to put forward proposals to the apex court of the land.
It can thus be seen that through the country’s constitution and laws, there are many restrictions on the freedom of expression and freedom of the media. The “Official Secret Act of 1923” is still operative; anything perceived as against the state or prejudicial to state interests is to be tried under this act. Classified matters cannot be published or even spoken of. The Safety and Telegraph Acts are also used for curbing the right of freedom of expression. The Newspapers, Periodicals and News Agencies Ordinance, 2002, is still in force, according to which no periodical or newspaper can be printed without permission from the Ministry of Information. This is a clear violation of article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), as well as the constitution of Pakistan. PEMRA is a regulatory body which gives out licenses for the production of any type of electronic channel; permission for this has to be taken from the government. Unlike in Europe or the USA, Pakistani individuals or organizations cannot simply make their own radio or TV channel as per their whims.
Contempt of court is another method of restricting freedom of expression. While the government says there is no law regarding contempt of court, the Supreme Court relies on the Contempt of Court Ordinance of 2004 to minimize freedom of expression, particularly when it comes to the decisions of the court.
There is a draft law on freedom of information in circulation, but it can be termed as mere lip service to show that something is being done. It does not define who will decide what is secret and what is not. Contrary to global practices, the government has kept everything secret until it is declared to be made public. Data collection and maintenance mechanisms are very poor in Pakistan. The draft law allows the government and its agencies to classify anything they want to be exempt from being made public, without any explanation necessary. The procedure to declare something secret has not been revealed. And the big question is, who exactly is authorized to declare anything secret?
Finally, Pakistan’s Constitution declares quite clearly that Pakistan is an Islamic country. With the country run on a religious basis, there simply cannot be any genuine freedom of expression. Moreover, after military rule ended in 1985, pressure groups and fundamentalists took on the state’s role to implement their own rules, as well as its tactics of coercion and intimidation. The role of the government has thus been reduced to a minimum, with fundamentalists and the military increasingly calling the shots.
Seriously all kinds of helpful data!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
canadian pharcharmy
mail order pharmacies
canada pharmacy online
With thanks, I appreciate it.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
visit poster’s website canadian pharmacy online highest rated canadian pharmacies canadian online pharmacies
prescription drugs canada
buying prescription drugs canada
buy prescription drugs online
mexican pharmacies
canadian pharmacy reviews
pharmacy online
Position clearly used..
https://nicktambone.com/
pharmacy prices canada drug prescription online global pharmacy canada
online pharmacy canada
pharmacy near me
pharmacies in canada
online pharmacy
board of pharmacy
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
Many thanks. A lot of forum posts.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
buy prescription drugs from canada canadian pharmacies-24h canadian pharmacy 365 canadian pharmacies online
canada drugs
canadian online pharmacy reviews
prescription drugs prices
online drugs
prescription drugs without doctor approval
pharmacy online
Effectively voiced certainly. !
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
rx price comparison canada pharmacy prescription online canadian pharmacies-24h
online pharmacies
canadian prescription drugs
online pharmacy reviews
best non prescription online pharmacies
canadian prescription drugstore
no prior prescription required pharmacy
Info nicely taken!.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
best non prescription online pharmacies canada pharmacy canadian prescription drugs north west pharmacy canada
buying prescription drugs canada
canadian pharma companies
internet pharmacy
canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
best online international pharmacies
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
Terrific write ups. With thanks!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
online canadian pharmacy canadian online pharmacies canada drugs online pharmacy north west pharmacy canada
canadian pharcharmy online
buying prescription drugs canada
rx pharmacy
canadian family pharmacy
discount pharmacy online
visit poster’s website
Wow lots of great facts.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canada pharmacies without script canada pharmaceutical online ordering canadian pharmacy viagra canadian pharmacies without an rx
canadian rx
canadapharmacy
pharmacy prices compare
drugs online
mexican pharmacies online
no prior prescription required pharmacy
Thanks a lot. Quite a lot of material!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
online canadian discount pharmacy london drugs canada canadian discount pharmacy canadian pharmacies without an rx
medication costs
canadian pharmacy viagra
drugs from canada
canadapharmacyonline.com
top rated canadian pharmacies online
mexican pharmacy online
Appreciate it, A lot of postings.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
prescription price comparison canada drug discount pharmacy online global pharmacy canada
canadadrugs
buy drugs online
pharmacy online
canada drugs pharmacy
canadapharmacy
top rated canadian pharmacies online
Appreciate it! An abundance of advice.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
best online pharmacies canada canadian pharmacies-24h discount pharmacy online aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
northwest pharmacy
cheap prescription drugs online
canada drugs online pharmacy
canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
Nicely put, Appreciate it.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
prescription drug assistance online pharmacies of canada canada pharmacy online canadian pharmacy
drug costs
cheap drugs online
highest rated canadian pharmacies
walgreens pharmacy
mexican pharmacies online
walgreens pharmacy
You suggested this effectively!
https://nicktambone.com/
cheap prescription drugs canadian pharmaceuticals online online pharmacies online pharmacies canada
canadian drug
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
buy cialis
pharmacies in canada
canadian pharmacy without prescription
drugs online
Thanks a lot! I value it!
http://talahicc.com/
pharmacies near me canadian pharmacy online trusted overseas pharmacies online pharmacies canada
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
online rx pharmacy
buy prescription drugs canada
ed meds online
prescription price comparison
my canadian pharmacy
Well voiced indeed! !
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
safe canadian online pharmacies canadian viagra canada pharmacies online pharmacy canadian online pharmacies
mexican pharmacies
prescription cost comparison
canada pharmacies
canadian viagra
canada drug
online canadian pharmacies
Nicely put. Kudos!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
pharmacy price compare canada pharmaceutical online ordering discount prescription drugs online canada pharmaceuticals online
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
cialis online
king pharmacy
no prior prescription required pharmacy
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
canada pharmacies online prescriptions
Useful data. With thanks!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
online pharmacies no prescription online pharmacies of canada prescription prices comparison canada online pharmacies
canadadrugs
canadian pharmacies top best
buy online prescription drugs
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
canadian online pharmacies
compare prescription prices
Great forum posts. Thanks!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian drugstore canadian viagra pharmacy without dr prescriptions canadian pharmacy online
compare rx prices
online canadian pharmacies
rx price comparison
best online pharmacies canada
mexican pharmacies
compare rx prices
You revealed this superbly.
https://nicktambone.com/
cheap prescription drugs canada online pharmacies discount prescription drugs online online pharmacies of canada
discount pharmaceuticals
pharmacy online mexico
buying prescription drugs canada
canadian rx
trust pharmacy canada
pharmacy tech
Amazing all kinds of useful data!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
international pharmacy global pharmacy canada online pharmacies no prescription canadian pharcharmy
canada online pharmacies
best canadian mail order pharmacies
most reliable canadian pharmacies
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
buy cialis
us pharmacy no prior prescription
Nicely put. Regards.
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian viagra canadian cialis king pharmacy canada drug
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
online drugs
international pharmacy
compare rx prices
pharmacy tech
canadian online pharmacies
You actually explained this really well.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
cheap prescription drugs london drugs canada pharmacy near me northwest pharmacy
prescription drugs online without
canadadrugs.com pharmacy
canadadrugs.com pharmacy
canadian discount pharmacy
canada pharmacies
drug price
Nicely put. With thanks!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
best canadian online pharmacy online pharmacies canada mexican online pharmacies canada drugs online
prescription drug assistance
prescription drug assistance
online drugstore
rx price comparison
pharmacy online store
pharmacy online store
Wow quite a lot of helpful info!
https://nicktambone.com/
canada pharmacy northwestpharmacy internet pharmacy top rated canadian pharmacies online
no prescription pharmacies
canadian prescription drugstore
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
canadian prescription drugstore
canadian family pharmacy
online canadian pharmacy
Lovely stuff, Thanks!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canadian prescriptions canadian viagra discount prescription drugs online canada pharmacy online
buy online prescription drugs
pharmacy cost comparison
ed meds online
canadian pharmacies top best
drug prices comparison
online rx pharmacy
You actually reported this really well!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
my canadian pharmacy canada online pharmacies canadian pharmacies online online pharmacies canada
canadian rx
best canadian online pharmacy
pain meds online without doctor prescription
overseas pharmacies
online canadian pharmacy
canadapharmacy com
Kudos, Helpful information!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
pharmacies in canada canadian pharmacies-24h prescription cost canada drugs online
canadapharmacy
overseas pharmacies
canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
prescription drugs prices
You suggested it very well.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
candrugstore com aarp approved canadian online pharmacies drugstore online canada drug
canadian drugstore online
canadian online pharmacies
rx online
no prescription pharmacy
canadian drugs
candrugstore com
Kudos! I like it.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian prescription drugs canada pharmacy canadian pharmacy king canadian pharmacies
canada drugs online pharmacy
mail order pharmacies
web medical information
prescription drugs online without doctor
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
prescription drugs online without
Good material. With thanks!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
buy prescription drugs online canadian online pharmacies canadian drug stores online canadian drugs
24 hour pharmacy
canadian drugs without prescription
best online pharmacies canada
canadian pharmacy 365
canadian pharmacies
safeway pharmacy
Wow lots of wonderful facts!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canada pharmacies online prescriptions canadian pharmacy online pharmacy price comparison canadian pharmacies online
canadian rx
international pharmacies that ship to the usa
canada drugs online pharmacy
mexican pharmacies online
discount pharmacy online
canadian pharmacy without prescription
You’ve made your stand extremely effectively..
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian viagra online pharmacies canada best online pharmacies canada northwest pharmacy
online pharmacy
canadian viagra
drug stores near me
the canadian pharmacy
<a href="http://meier-mediadesign.ch/?s=+Incredible+plenty+of+superb+information.+http%3A%2F%2Fcanadianpharmaciesnnm.com%2F+canadian+pharma+companies+canadian+pharmacy+online+canadian+discount+pharmacy+canada+pharmaceuticals+online+%0D%0Aonline+drugs+%0D%0Apharmacy+online+store+%0D%0Apharmacy+online+store+%0D%0Acanadian+pharmacy+%0D%0Acanadian+online+pharmacies+prescription+drugs+%0D%0Acanada+drugs+online+pharmacy”>online pharmacy without prescription
buy prescription drugs canada
You said it exceptionally well.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
no prescription pharmacy global pharmacy canada buying prescription drugs canada canadian online pharmacy
drug costs
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
prescription drug
medication costs
canadian drug store
best non prescription online pharmacies
Valuable content. Regards!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
highest rated canadian pharmacies canada online pharmacies canadian pharmacy reviews london drugs canada
canadian online pharmacy reviews
canadian pharmacy online canada
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
web medical information
prescription cost
get prescription online
You said it nicely..
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
drugs online canada online pharmacies online prescription drugs canadian viagra
canadian prescriptions
compare prescription prices
best non prescription online pharmacies
canada pharmacy online orders
24 hour pharmacy
global pharmacy canada
You revealed it terrifically!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian rx pharmacy online mexican pharmacies shipping to usa discount pharmaceuticals canada pharmaceuticals online
pain meds online without doctor prescription
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
canadian drug store
mexican online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
canadian prescription
Seriously quite a lot of fantastic facts.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian mail order pharmacies northwestpharmacy internet pharmacy canada pharmaceutical online ordering
prescription drugs canada
canadapharmacy com
no prescription pharmacy
best online canadian pharcharmy
pharmacy online store
online pharmacies canada
Amazing all kinds of amazing tips!
https://nicktambone.com/
drug stores near me canadian viagra canada drug pharmacy canada drugs
pharmacy cost comparison
canadian drugstore online
overseas pharmacy forum
top rated canadian pharmacies online
buy cialis
canada drugs online pharmacy
Reliable facts. With thanks.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
buy drugs online canada pharmaceutical online ordering canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs canadian pharmacies-24h
canada drugs
my canadian pharmacy
online pharmacy no prescription
pharmacies near me
mail order pharmacies
mail order pharmacy
With thanks! Lots of stuff!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian pharmacies that are legit canada pharmaceutical online ordering canada pharmacies without script canadian pharmacies-24h
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
prescription prices comparison
canadian pharmacy
canada pharmacy no prescription
pharmacy prices
prescription prices comparison
Very good posts. Many thanks.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian pharmacy online canada trust pharmacy canada best online international pharmacies top rated canadian pharmacies online
discount pharmacy online
canada drugs online
online canadian discount pharmacy
my canadian pharmacy
no prescription online pharmacy
canadian prescription drugstore
Excellent postings. Thanks a lot!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canada pharmacies canadian pharmacies canadian rx pharmacy online aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
canadian pharmacies top best
international pharmacies that ship to the usa
pain meds online without doctor prescription
drugs online
drug price
canada pharmacies online
Fantastic write ups. Appreciate it!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian pharmacies without prescriptions north west pharmacy canada buy prescription drugs from canada canadian pharmacies without an rx
pharmacy near me
visit poster’s website
pharmacy prices compare
online rx pharmacy
canada drug pharmacy
canadian pharmacy online
Thanks a lot! I value it!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian meds canadian pharmacies without an rx canadian pharmacy no prescription needed canada pharmacy online
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
canadian rx pharmacy online
buy prescription drugs from canada
drugs online
online rx pharmacy
pharmacy near me
Thanks a lot! Quite a lot of data!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
prescription drug canada drugs online northwestpharmacy canadian pharmacies-24h
canadian prescription drugs
canada pharmacy online reviews
northwest pharmacy canada
approved canadian pharmacies online
board of pharmacy
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
Terrific data, Kudos.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
online canadian discount pharmacy canadian pharmaceuticals online online canadian pharmacy canadian online pharmacy
prescription pricing
canadian online pharmacy reviews
cheap drugs online
canadian prescription drugstore
canadian drugstore
canadian drug store
Great material. Thanks a lot.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
pharmacy drug store north west pharmacy canada no prescription pharmacy london drugs canada
medical information online
buying prescription drugs canada
buy drugs online
internet pharmacy
prescription drug cost
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
Valuable knowledge. Thanks.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canada pharmacies northwestpharmacy safe canadian online pharmacies top rated canadian pharmacies online
prescription prices comparison
online rx pharmacy
canadian prescription drugs
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
online drugs
my canadian pharmacy
Reliable data. Appreciate it!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canada drugs online pharmacy canadian pharcharmy best non prescription online pharmacies northwest pharmacy
canadian online pharmacies
buy prescription drugs from canada
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
rx online
prescription drugs canada
trusted overseas pharmacies
Lovely information, Thanks.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
discount drugs online pharmacy canada drugs canadian drugs north west pharmacy canada
best online pharmacies no prescription
prescription price comparison
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
rx pharmacy
online drugs
online pharmacy without prescription
Seriously a lot of useful knowledge.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
canadian discount pharmacy canadian pharmaceuticals online canadian pharmacy viagra brand trust pharmacy canada
canada drug
canada pharmacy online
canada pharmacies online
drug price
canadian meds
online pharmacy canada