Human rights defenders under attack in Thailand, again
Thailand Desk, Asian Human Rights Commission
Staff members of the Thailand Desk of the Asian Human Rights Commission have assembled this note on the threats to the authors of the report featured in this special issue of article 2 on ‘Torture in Thailand’s deep south’ from public media and human rights groups’ sources.
The Cross Cultural Foundation (CrCF) is an organization that monitors and documents cases of torture and ill-treatment in Thailand. In 2002, The CrCF was officially registered and since then the group has worked closely with its partners, such as the National Human Rights Commission of Thailand, Lawyers Council of Thailand, and Thai Volunteer Services to facilitate legal aid and access to justice for vulnerable groups.
In 2014 and 2015, the CrCF together Duayjai Group, which is based in Thailand’s deep south to support people who suffer injustice at the hands of state officers, and the Pattani Human Rights Organization (HAP) worked together to produce a torture report compiling and analyzing 54 cases of torture and ill treatment in Yala, Pattani and Narathiwat provinces, southernmost Thailand.
The report was partly funded by the United Nations Voluntary Fund for Victims of Torture, established under the UN General Assembly resolution 36/151 in 1981. Somchai Homlaor, president of the CrCF, Pornpen Khongkachonkiet, its director, and Anchana Heemmina, director of the Duayjai Group, worked as co-editors of the report.
Before the public release of the report, the authors and editors went to the trouble of submitting it directly to the army. On 8 January 2016, Anchana personally handed the report to General Aksara Kerdphol, the chief negotiator for the peace talks as appointed by 2014 coup leader Prime Minister General Prayut Chan-O-Cha, and the Fourth Army Region Commander, Lt Gen Wiwat Pathompak. On behalf of the human rights defenders, she requested of the generals that they initiate investigations into the cases compiled from the interviews of 54 victims of torture while being held in custody of security officers during 2015, 2014, and earlier. In a press release issued at the time, the groups said that,
“By submitting the report directly to the high level agencies with direct responsibility, we hope that an effort shall be made to uncover the truth. It helps to keep alive the hope of the taskforce [comprising of CrCF, Duayjai and HAP] that the end of torture could be achieved and that the death in custody of Mr. Abduldayib Dolah on 4 December 2015 [see annex to the report in this issue of article 2] would be made the last of its kind in the Deep South… if a ban is publicly made on the use of torture [and] a genuine effort is being made to investigate the cases fairly and to bring the perpetrators to justice even though they could be just a fraction of the officers [then] we hope it will be the beginning of the peace talks in earnest…”
On 10 February 2016, the CrCF and the Duayjai Group launched the report, entitled Torture and Ill Treatment in the Deep South Documented in 2014-2015. The army responded not by considering the allegations and indicating that it might act upon them, but on the contrary, by threatening all three editors and the human rights groups who supported them in the documentation.
As noted by the Asian Human Rights Commission in a statement (AHRC-STM-019-2016) one day after the release of the report, Major General Banpot Poonpien, the spokesperson for Thailand’s Internal Security Operations Command (ISOC), promptly accused the human rights groups of fabricating accounts of torture to obtain funding from abroad. He also asked whether or not the groups had the mandate to investigate the work of state officers.
Incredibly, the officer ended his statement with a threat that they could be committing defamation by issuing a report referring to international human rights law: “Why [are the report’s authors] invoking just the international laws while forsaking the methods of inquiry provided for by domestic law, since such an act could possibly amount to a defamatory offence,” he said.
On February 14, Colonel Suratep, head of the Civil Society Organisations unit in ISOC, contacted Anchana and other activists who were involved in compiling the report and summoned them for a discussion. Anchana presented herself at Sirinthon Army Camp in Yala Province for the discussion with seven security officers. The meeting lasted two and a half hours, during which the officers questioned her about the cases in the torture report. The officers expressed their discontent with the report and requested the human rights defender to henceforth submit all of her publications to the ISOC prior to their release. She refused to do so.
On 8 June 2016, Pornpen Khongkachonkiet got information through a phone conversation with ISOC Region 4 that it had already sought power of attorney from the army and had submitted a complaint to Pattani Town Police Station on 17 May 2016 for criminal defamation under section 328 of the Thai Criminal Code, and violation of the Computer Crimes Act B.E.2550 (2007), section 14(1). Authorities have already interrogated six witnesses and the police case file number is 704/2559.
Defending the decision to prosecute, the Thai military said that this was its way of acting to defend the honour of the country. Colonel Pramote Promin, a spokesperson for ISOC Region 4 rebuked human rights groups abroad that criticized the decision—groups like Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, Frontline Defenders, and Lawyers’ Rights Watch Canada (see letter concerning the case appended to this article)—alleging that the three domestic groups had intentionally distorted facts to cast the military in bad light.
In an even more sinister development, he indicated that the army had succeeded in identifying, on the basis of the de-identified information in the report, 18 of the cases in the report, but that in none of the cases was there any evidence of torture. He imputed that the other cases were fabrications.
This is not the first instance that the army has attempted to sue the three human rights defenders. In September 2014 Somchai Homlaor and Pornpen Khongkachonkiet, as well as their organization, faced criminal defamation and computer-related crimes charges filed by Task Force Unit 41. The case was eventually dropped by the decision of the public prosecutor in June 2015, following an international campaign denouncing the harassment and intimidation of these human right defenders for their legitimate and crucial human rights work.
From 13 to 15 June 2016, Somchai, Pornpen and Anchana received summons to present themselves to the police on 26 June 2016, but they all they postponed the meeting to 26 July 2016 because their lawyer had not had sufficient time to examine the case file. All three have affirmed that whether they are charged or not, the CrCF and Duayjai will continue to monitor and document cases of torture and ill treatment in Thailand.
Fantastic info, Many thanks.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra free sites computer edinburgh pages
viagra pills
las vegas about kamagra viagra
generic viagra online
This is nicely expressed. .
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
jelquing on viagra
viagra generic
viagra coupons
viagra for women
This is nicely expressed! !
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
find search viagra edinburgh soft
viagra for sale uk
compare cialis viagra levitra
viagra online
Kudos! An abundance of postings.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
buy viagra locally
viagra without a doctor prescription
legitimate generic viagra
viagra for women
You actually expressed it perfectly!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
how to order viagra online
viagra generic
discount viagra online a href
viagra online
Perfectly expressed genuinely! !
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
nitric oxide and viagra cgmp
viagra pills
file viewtopic t 72 viagra
generic viagra online
You made your point very clearly!.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra prescription price
viagra without a doctor prescription
women’s viagra increase female libido
cheap viagra
Amazing loads of terrific information!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra gone wrong funny pic
generic viagra
storing viagra
generic viagra 100mg
Useful knowledge. Thank you.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
law suits against viagra
viagra 100mg
over the counter viagra
viagra for sale uk
Good content, Thanks!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
fake generic viagra
viagra online
viagra uk cheap purchase buy
viagra online
Useful forum posts. Many thanks.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
take alternative viagra and take nitrates
viagra generic
viagra milligrams
buy viagra online
Thank you, Ample stuff.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra pen new version
viagra for sale uk
how good is generic indian viagra
buy viagra online
Amazing a lot of excellent material.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
male enhancment viagra
buy generic viagra
viagra on airplane
generic viagra 100mg
Helpful facts. Regards.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
helping viagra work
viagra for sale uk
will viagra give you an erection
generic viagra
Lovely information. Thanks!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
reviews of viagra suppliers
generic viagra 100mg
ciala vs viagra
viagra pills
Amazing plenty of terrific advice!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
test done on viagra
generic viagra 100mg
lavitra vs viagra
generic viagra online
Terrific stuff, Thank you.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
herbal viagra
generic viagra
does viagra make you erect
viagra online
Appreciate it, Numerous postings.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
viagra producer
viagra generic
i belive in viagra
viagra pills
Nicely put. With thanks.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
doees viagra work for women
buy generic viagra
ages forn viagra use
viagra pills
Regards. Good stuff.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
settlement on viagra in the courts
generic viagra
vardenafil viagra cialis
viagra without a doctors prescription
Really quite a lot of fantastic information.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
loss viagra prescription
viagra generic
viagra generic oregon
viagra without a doctors prescription
You mentioned it perfectly.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
soft tabs generic viagra
viagra pills
wal-mart hefei viagra
viagra without a doctors prescription
Nicely put, Thanks a lot.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
viagra and sinusitis
viagra generic
viagra no prescription overnite shipping
generic viagra
Regards. Lots of knowledge!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
subaction showcomments viagra smyle older
viagra for sale uk
viagra lavitra cialis
viagra for women
Terrific posts. Appreciate it!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
blood presure viagra
buy viagra
cyclobenzaprine and viagra
buy generic viagra
Fantastic facts. Thank you!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
aspirin and viagra together
generic viagra 100mg
testimonials viagra treatment
viagra for women
You actually mentioned that effectively!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra 50mg online
generic viagra 100mg
viagra canadian tv ad
viagra without a doctor prescription
Really all kinds of beneficial tips.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
woman’s viagra
generic viagra 100mg
viagra single dose
generic viagra 100mg
You said it adequately.!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
usa online pharmacies viagra
generic viagra 100mg
were does viagra come from
cheap viagra
Regards, A good amount of information.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra in malaysia
cheap viagra
take viagra before using penis pump
viagra generic
This is nicely said! !
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra like drugs for female sexuality
viagra generic
ultralow price viagra
viagra for women
You actually explained that perfectly!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
birth of a viagra salesman
generic viagra
viagra tylenol
cheap viagra
You have made your point!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
information medical viagra
viagra without a doctors prescription
viagra samle
viagra for women
Amazing forum posts. Regards.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
viagra rxmeds
generic viagra
compare viagra to cialis and levitra
viagra for sale uk
Seriously quite a lot of beneficial tips.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
health information on viagra
generic viagra online
viagra prescription medication
viagra for sale uk
Lovely material, Kudos.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
what if viagra foes not work
cheap viagra
brand name viagra by mail
generic viagra 100mg
You said it very well.!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
cheapest 4 quantity of viagra
buy viagra
viagra by the pill
viagra for sale uk
Awesome facts. Cheers.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra p5 inhibitor
viagra for women
viagra soft tabs review
viagra for women
You said it adequately..
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra trial pack canada
viagra 100mg
viagra homeopatic
buy generic viagra
You actually stated that wonderfully.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra free sites computer news
viagra online
discount viagra cialis levitra online canada
viagra pills
Thank you! I value this!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
coleman 2000 viagra elite trailer
viagra without a doctors prescription
indian viagra caverta rupees
viagra without a doctors prescription
Superb data. Regards.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
best buy viagra viagra
cheap viagra
viagra for sale in gibralter
generic viagra 100mg
Many thanks! Ample advice!
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
ordering generic viagra in canada
viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra ceapest prices
cheap viagra
Kudos. Fantastic stuff.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
legit viagra
generic viagra online
sample cialis lavitra viagra
buy viagra online
Fine knowledge. Thanks!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
viagra dependency
viagra online
food alternetives to viagra
buy viagra
Cheers. Quite a lot of facts!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
what is viagra medication
viagra generic
celas and viagra
viagra without a doctors prescription
Cheers! A lot of information!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra and sinusitis
viagra generic
medical history of viagra use
generic viagra online
Thanks a lot. I enjoy it.
https://www.viagrawithoutadoctorsmim.com/
viagra interaction with nebivolol
buy generic viagra
viagra tricks
generic viagra 100mg
You actually expressed that adequately!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorntx.com/
metoprolol er succinate and viagra
viagra online
viagra doctor torrance
viagra 100mg
Thanks a lot. Quite a lot of posts.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
50mg vs 100mg viagra
viagra generic
psa viagra
viagra 100mg
Helpful advice. With thanks!
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra doctor l a
buy viagra online
viagra use paypal
buy generic viagra
Truly quite a lot of terrific info.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
best and cheapest viagra pills
viagra for sale uk
erection viagra photo galleries sex
viagra generic
Nicely put, Cheers!
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra and amiben online
viagra without a doctors prescription
mixing zanidip and viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
With thanks! I value this.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
female viagra fda approved products
viagra generic
viagra cialis compare
generic viagra 100mg
You expressed this fantastically.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
fermale viagra
viagra without a doctors prescription
2 comparison levitra viagra
buy generic viagra
Lovely facts, Thanks.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
viagra on the lake
buy generic viagra
pharmacy silagra brand name viagra cumwithuscom
viagra without a doctors prescription
Truly all kinds of valuable facts.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
generic viagra versus cialis pills
viagra 100mg
how well does viagra work
buy generic viagra
Thanks, I enjoy it.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctorbnt.com/
viagra by mail
generic viagra 100mg
arguments for coverage of viagra
buy viagra online
Cheers! Ample advice.
https://www.viagrawithoutdoctormsn.com/
effects viagra 200mg
viagra generic
viagra find free edinburgh computer
viagra pills
Great data. Thank you.
https://www.genericviagracubarx.com/
viagra side effect interaction
generic viagra
viagra orders
viagra for women
Regards. A good amount of content!
http://viagrawithoutadoctormsn.com/
you made everything possible again viagra
cheap viagra
medication online viagra
generic viagra 100mg
Well voiced really. .
http://viagrawithoutadoctormsn.com/
kamagra viagra oral jelly
cheap viagra
what happens is women take viagra
viagra generic
Terrific stuff. Appreciate it!
http://viagrapego.com/
buying viagra online title object object
viagra for women
viagra telephone
buy viagra
You actually revealed this really well.
http://viagrapego.com/
herb supplements that react with viagra
viagra online
investors beware con herbal viagra
viagra for women
Thank you. Very good stuff!
http://viagrapego.com/
can i take viagra
viagra online
viagra vision
viagra generic
Thanks. Fantastic information!
http://viagrawithoutadoctormsn.com/
viagra online bestellen
generic viagra 100mg
viagra sverige
viagra 100mg
Wow tons of useful knowledge!
http://viagrawithoutadoctorsntx.com/
viagra discount sales
viagra without a doctor prescription
viagra keeps girl alive january jessica
viagra pills
Nicely put. Appreciate it!
http://viagrapego.com/
viagra achat
generic viagra 100mg
pokemon gold buy viagra
generic viagra 100mg
You actually expressed it really well.
http://viagrawithoutadoctormsn.com/
viagra miracle drug or miracle drug
cheap viagra
red and yellow chinese viagra
viagra pills